/ Mathematics

Group Operations

The Symmetric Group

A permutation of a set $M$ ($M$ for Menge, the German word for set) is a bijective function $\sigma: M \to M$.

As an example, consider the set $M := \{ \Delta, \circ, \star \}$; now one such permutation $\sigma$ might be defined to do the following: \[ \Delta \mapsto \circ \, , \, \circ \mapsto \Delta \, , \, \star \mapsto \star . \] The star is fixed, but the triangle and the circle are permutated.

For a more concrete example, the shape or the nature of the objects in the set does not matter, all that must be known is the number of objects in $M$, called the cardinality $| M |$ of $M$. Let $M := \{ 1, 2, 3 \}$ be a set with $3$ elements, then the above permutation can then be described by
\[ 1 \mapsto 2 \, , \, 2 \mapsto 1 \, , \, 3 \mapsto 3. \] The third element is left fixed, while the first two are permutated.

Generally, as such permutations are bijective, they are invertible, with their inverse being a, probably different, permutation of $M$ as well. The composition of permutations is again a, probably different, permutation of $M$. There also clearly exists a permutation that does nothing, the identity, namely $m \mapsto m$, for each element $m \in M$. Therefore, the set of all the permutations of a set $M$ is a group, the so called symmetry group $\operatorname{Sym}M := \{ \sigma : M \to M \, \mid \, \sigma \text{ bijective } \}$ of $M$.

For a finite set $M := \{1,2, \dots n\}$, the symmetric group $S_n$ of $M$, or the symmetric group of order $n$, is defined as the permutation group of $M$: $S_n := \operatorname{Sym}\{1, 2, \dots, n\}$. Note that the order of $S_n$ is $n!$.

One can think of those permutations as the symmetries of an object. Imagine a square rotated by $\frac{\pi}{2}$, the actual vertices have moved, but the square still looks the same. Can you figure out all of the eight symmetries of the square?

Symmetry Group of the Square

If you ever wanted to see the mathematical beauty of symmetry, think about visiting the Qalat Al-Hamra, or the Alhambra, in Grenada, Spain.

Al-Hamra

Cayley's Theorem

Arthur Cayley was a British mathematician, and probably the first man to clearly define the concept of a group. One of his famous theorems states that every group is isomorphic to a group of permutations.

Arthur Cayley

Two objects are said to be isomorphic, if there exists an isomorphism, which is a bijective homomorphism (from the ancient Greek words ὁμός (homós), which means equal or similar, and μορφή (morphé), which means form), between the two objects. Homomorphisms are structure preservering maps that identify objects which, although looking differently, are essentially the same.

To prove the theorem, let $\operatorname{Sym}G$ denote the symmetry group of a group $(G, \cdot)$. The basic idea is that each element $g \in G$ corresponds to a permutation of $G$:
\[ \sigma: G \to \operatorname{Sym}G \, , \, g \mapsto \sigma(g) =: \sigma_g, \] with \[ \sigma_g : G \to G \, , \, h \mapsto \sigma_g(h) = g.h := g \cdot h. \] Since $G$ is a group, it is clear that $\sigma_g$ is bijective, thus indeed a permutation of $G$.

Furthermore, $G$ being a group ensures that $\sigma$ is an injective homomorphism, which means that $G$ is indeed isomorphic to a subgroup of $\operatorname{Sym}G$. Subgroups of $\operatorname{Sym}G$ are often called permutation groups and are denoted by $\operatorname{Per}G$.

Group Operations

With Cayley's theorem, it is now clear how to define a group operation on a set: An operation of a group $(G, \cdot)$ on a set $M$ is a homomorphism $\sigma$ of $G$ into the symmetry group of $M$ defined as above. An operation thus provides a mapping $G \times M \to M$, $(g,m) \mapsto \sigma_g(m) = g.m = g \cdot m$. We also say that $G$ acts on $M$.

Obviously the following two properties hold:

  1. $\forall m \in M \, : \, e.m = m$, where $e_G$ is the unit element of $G$.
  2. $\forall g_1, g_2 \in G, m \in M \, : \, g_1(g_2.m) = (g_1g_2).m$.

Conversely, a map $G \times M \to M \, , \, (g,m) \mapsto g.m$ satisfying these two properties defines a permutation for each $g \in G$. We thus obtain a homomorphism from $G$ into $\operatorname{Sym}G$. So an operation of $G$ on $M$ could also be defined as a mapping $G \times M \to M$ with the two properties from above.

The Orbit

Let $m \in M$ be arbitrary chosen but fixed. The subset of $M$ consisting of the images of $m$ under operation by elements of $G$ is denoted by $G.m := \{ g.m \, \mid \, g \in G \}$ and called the orbit of $m$ under $G$.

Clearly, all of the orbits define a partition of $M = \bigcup_{m \in M}G.m$. If an element $m \in M$ belongs to the orbit of both $m_1 \in M$ and $m_2 \in M$, then there exist $g_1, g_2 \in G$ such, that $m = g_1.m_1 = g_2.m_2$. Since $G$ is a group, this implies that $m_1 = g_1^{-1} \cdot g_2.m_2$ and $m_2 = g_2^{-1} \cdot g_1.m_1$, thus $m_1$ belongs to the orbit of $m_2$ and vice-versa. In conclusion: $G.m_1 = G.m_2$, thus, by chosing representatives $v$ for each orbit, we can write \[M = \bigcup_{v \in V} G.v,\] where $V$ denotes the set of the chosen representatives.

A group operation is called transitive, or G is said to act transitively on $M$, if there is only one orbit: $M = G.m$, for any $m \in M$, that is, for all $m_1, m_2 \in M$ there exists $g \in G$ such, that $m_2 = g.m_1$.

The Stabilizer

Let $m \in M$ be arbitrarily chosen but fixed. The set of elements $g \in G$ which leave $m$ fixed, that is $g.m = m$, is a subgroup of $G$, the so-called isotropy group of $m$ in $G$, or the stabilizer of $m$ under the action of $G$, denoted by $G_m := \{ g \in G \, \mid \, g.m = m \}$. An element $m \in M$ is called a fixed point of $G$, if $G_m = G$, in other words, if it is fixed by each operation.

Obviously the kernel $\operatorname{ker}\sigma = \{g \in G \, \mid \, \forall m \in M \, : \,g.m = m \}$ of a group operation is the intersection of all the isotropy groups: $\operatorname{ker}\sigma = \bigcap_{m \in M}G_m$. This is the set of all the elements of $G$ which leave all the elements of $M$ fixed.

A group operation is said to be faithful, if its kernel is trivial, i.e. if $\operatorname{ker}\sigma = \{ e_G \}$.

The Orbit-Stabilizer Theorem

The size of the orbit of an element $m \in M$ is the index, the relative size, of the stabilizer of $m$ in $G$:
\[ | G.m | = [ G : G_m ]. \]
For a finite set $G$, this corresponds to:
\[ | G.m | = \frac{| G |}{|G_m|}.\]
Note that in particular, the size of any orbit divides the order, or the cardinality, of the group.

For a proof, we must define a bijective map $\varphi$ between $G.m$ and $G / G_m := \{ g.G_m \, \mid \, g \in G \}$, the set of left cosets of $G_m$ in $G$. We can do so as follows: \[\varphi: G.m \to G/G_m \, , \, n = g.m \mapsto g.G_m. \]

The first thing to check is whether $\varphi$ is well-defined, as for a given $n$, as above, the choice of $g$ in $n = g.m$ is not unique, as there is no bijection between $G$ and $G.m$ in general. Suppose that $n = g_1.m = g_2.m$, then clearly \[g_2^{-1}g_1.m = m \Leftrightarrow g_1.G_m = g_2.G_m,\] thus the image of $n$ under $f$ does not depend on the choice of $g$, since the images are still in the same coset.

By the definition of $\varphi$ it is clear that $\varphi$ is surjective. To see that it is also injective, assume that $\varphi(m_1) = \varphi(m_2)$, for $m_1 = g_1.m \in G.m$ and $m_2 = g_2.m \in G.m$. Then, as $g_1.G_m = g_2.G_m$, i.e. $g_2^{-1} \cdot g_1 \in G_m$, it follows that $g_2^{-1} \cdot g_1.m = m$, and in conclusion $g_1 \cdot m = g_2 \cdot m$, as desired.

The Orbit-Counting Theorem

In the case of a finite group operating on a finite set, a theorem, probably due to Ferdinand Georg Frobenius, allows us to count the number of orbits $n_o$:

\[ n_o = \frac{1}{|G|} \cdot \sum\limits_{g \in G} | M_g |, \] where $M_g := \{ m \in M \, \mid \, g.m = m\}$ denotes the subset of all the elements of $M$ fixed by $g \in G$.

Georg Frobenius

In other words, the number of orbits under a group operation is the average number of points, or elements of $M$, that are left fixed by the elements of $G$.

To prove this, we use the Orbit-Stabilizer Theorem:

\[\begin{align*}
\sum\limits_{g \in G}|M_g| &= |\{(g,m) \in G \times M \, \mid \, g.m = m \}| \\ &= \sum\limits_{m \in M} | G_m | \\ &= \sum\limits_{m \in M} \frac{|G|}{|G.m|}.
\end{align*}\]
Further using the fact that $M$ can be written as a disjoint union of the orbits under the group operation, we get the desired result:
\[
\begin{align*}
\frac{|G|}{|G.m|} &= |G| \cdot \sum\limits_{m \in M}\frac{1}{|G.m|} \\ &= |G| \cdot \sum\limits_{v \in V}1 \\ &= |G| \cdot n_o.
\end{align*}
\]


Exercises

Exercise 1

Show that $| S_n | = n!$.

Exercise 2

Prove that $D_3$, the dihedral group of order $6$, is isomorphic to $S_3$.

Exercise 3

Prove that the isotropy group is indeed a subgroup of $G$.


References

Literature

  • Algebra, by Serge Lang
  • Algebra I, by Rudolf Scharlau

Art